As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.

This post may contain affiliate links. If you buy through them, The Funny Beaver may earn a commission at no extra cost to you.

Short version: the Apple Pencil 2nd generation we reviewed is still sold, but it doesn’t work with newer iPads like the iPad Pro (M4/M5) or iPad Air (M2 and later). For those, get the Apple Pencil Pro (2024). The basic iPad (A16) only works with the Apple Pencil (USB-C) or the 1st generation. Always check which iPad you have before you buy.

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. This post contains affiliate links, so The Funny Beaver may earn a commission if you buy through them, at no extra cost to you.

The Apple Pencil turns an iPad into a notebook, sketchbook and PDF markup tool. The tricky part is that Apple now sells several, and they’re not interchangeable. Here’s how they compare, based on Apple’s compatibility and feature pages (we didn’t test them hands-on).

Apple Pencil Pro vs USB-C vs 2nd generation: what’s different

Pencil (2nd gen) Pencil (USB-C) Pencil Pro
Works with Older iPad Pro (11-inch 1st–4th gen, 12.9-inch 3rd–6th gen), iPad Air 4/5, iPad mini 6 iPad (A16), iPad (10th gen), iPad mini, iPad Air and iPad Pro models iPad Pro (M4, M5), iPad Air (M2, M3, M4), iPad mini (A17 Pro)
Pressure sensitivity Not in Apple’s current feature table No Yes
Squeeze, barrel roll, haptics No No Yes
Find My No No Yes
Charging and pairing Magnetic, on the iPad USB-C cable Magnetic, on the iPad

Specs from Apple’s Pencil compatibility page, Apple’s Apple Pencil page. Checked October 2026.

What matters in real use

  • Compatibility is everything. A Pencil that doesn’t match your iPad simply won’t pair.
  • Artists want pressure. The USB-C model skips pressure sensitivity, so it’s better for notes than painting.
  • Find My saves the day. The Pro is the only one you can locate when it rolls under the couch.
  • Squeeze is a real shortcut. On the Pro, a squeeze opens a tool palette without hunting through menus.

Who should buy which

  • Buy the Apple Pencil Pro for a new iPad Pro, iPad Air (M2 or later) or iPad mini (A17 Pro).
  • Buy the Apple Pencil (USB-C) for the basic iPad (A16) or 10th gen, mostly for note-taking.
  • Keep the 2nd generation if you have an older iPad Pro, Air 4/5 or mini 6. It’s still a great Pencil.
  • Not sure which iPad you have? Settings > General > About shows the model name. Our iPad (A16) review explains the basic iPad.

Gift it to: a student who takes notes on an iPad, a doodler, or a coworker who prints every PDF just to sign it. Check their iPad model first.

Check Price on Amazon

Keep reading

Next Page >