Short version: the BigMouth Hook Line and Stinker toilet fishing game we featured has no sellers left on Amazon. The closest current version is the Potty Fisher toilet fishing game: an adjustable rod, a water tank, a lake mat, four fish and a “Do Not Disturb” door hanger. Same joke, still undefeated at white elephant parties.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. This post contains affiliate links, so The Funny Beaver may earn a commission if you buy through them, at no extra cost to you.
Like fishing? Like sitting? Now you can do both at once. A toilet fishing game is the gag gift that gets passed around the whole party before anyone admits they want it. Here’s what’s in the box, based on the listing (we didn’t test it hands-on, and our bathroom thanks us).
Hook Line and Stinker vs Potty Fisher: what’s different
| Hook Line and Stinker (our old pick) | Potty Fisher (current version) | |
|---|---|---|
| Availability | No sellers on Amazon | In stock on Amazon |
| Rod | Fishing pole | Adjustable, 9.5 to 15.75 inches |
| Fish | Included | 4 colored fish |
| Extras | Lake mat, door sign | Water tank (about 11.75 in), cotton lake mat (28 x 36.25 in), door hanger |
Specs from the Potty Fisher listing on Amazon. Checked October 2026.
Label check: Potty Fisher is a different brand’s version of the same gag.
What matters in real use
- The door hanger sells it. “Fishing Game In Progress” is the funniest part of the box.
- Kids love it too. It doubles as a goofy bath-time or rainy-day game.
- Know your audience. Great for the fishing-obsessed uncle, questionable for the office party.
- Golfer in the family? Pair it with the Potty Putter toilet golf game.
Who should buy it
- Get the Potty Fisher for anglers with a sense of humor and white elephant swaps.
- Want a real fishing gift? See our fishing gifts for dads.
Gift it to: the dad who checks the fishing report daily, the brother who spends 30 minutes in the bathroom, or your favorite coworker with a sense of humor.
Check Price on Amazon
